MVC: the view model

The ComicShop application we’ve presented so far has been quite basic, in that it does nothing more than allow the user to store comics in a local database, and display a list of these comics on the home page. In the process of creating the application, though, we’ve shown the division of labour between the model (where the data are stored and manipulated), the controller (which handles requests from the user and decides which view to display), and the view (which creates the actual HTML that is sent back to the browser).

You might think that, having covered all three components for which MVC is named, we’re finished with the basics. However, there is another logical component that forms part of the design when the application becomes anything more than very simple. This is the view model. (The view model occupies a more central position in another design system known as MVVM (thanks Stuart!), but we’ll leave a discussion of that until later.)

To illustrate the need for a view model (and to explain what it is), suppose we wanted to add a web page that displayed a summary of the comics in the database by listing each unique title followed by the number of comics of that title in the database. Ultimately, we’d like to display this information as a table in HTML, where each row in the table consists of a string (the title) and an int (the count for that title). To obtain this information, we need to query the database and do a count of each title returned. Where should this work be done?

One option is that the controller queries the database for a complete list of comics (as it does for the page that displays the complete list), and sends this list as is to the view, leaving the view to count up the number of comics for each title and then display the results. This isn’t very efficient, since the view is being forced to do a lot of stuff that has nothing to do with the display of the page.

Another option is that the controller does the calculations itself and then packages up the results and sends them to the view for display. That seems a little better, since at least the view is being cluttered with calculations. However, it isn’t really the job of the controller either, since its job is mainly to route the page request from the user to the correct view.

The solution currently accepted as best practice is to have the controller create a view model which is then sent to the view. The view model is a mirror in C# code of the data that the view requires in order to produce the HTML. In the case of our ComicShop summary page, we’d like a list of rows for the table, where each row contains the title and count for a group of comics. We therefore create a class representing a single row in the table, which looks like this:

namespace ComicShop.Models
  public class ComicSummary
    public string Title { get; set; }
    public int Count { get; set; }

The idea is now to have the controller construct the view model as an IEnumerable<ComicSummary> list (that is, a collection of ComicSummary objects that implements the IEnumerable interface), and that is what gets sent to the view. This list is the view model for the view that displays the summary information. It contains only the information that the view needs, and doesn’t require the view to do any further calculation.

Where should this list be constructed? To keep the controller clean, the construction shouldn’t be done directly inside the controller. Farming the process out to a separate class also fits in with the design we adopted when implementing unit testing, since we’d like to be able to test the summary-generation code in the controller without directly accessing the database. A sensible place to put the list-building code, then, is in the classes (one for testing and one for running normally) that implement the IComicRepository interface that we designed in the post on unit testing.

When we’re extracting the information from the database, we can actually do all the calculations required using LINQ. Here’s the method in the ComicRepository class:

    public ComicContext database = new ComicContext("ComicContextDb");
    public IEnumerable<ComicSummary> GetSummaries()
      var summaries = database.ComicBooks.Select(book => book).OrderBy(book => book.Title).
        GroupBy(comic => comic.Title,
        (title, titleGroup) => new ComicSummary
          Title = title,
          Count = titleGroup.Count()
      return  summaries;

The first line in the method is the LINQ code that selects all the comics, orders them by title, and then applies the GroupBy() method to sort them into groups where the key to each group is the Title field. The second argument to GroupBy() is a function which takes two parameters: the first is the title of the comic, and the second (titleGroup) is the group of comics with that title. We then construct a ComicSummary object containing the title and the count of comics in that group. The final returned object is the required IEnumerable<ComicSummary> list.

Back in the HomeController class, we add an action for the Summary page:

    public ViewResult Summary()
      IEnumerable<ComicSummary> summaries = comicRepository.GetSummaries();
      return View(summaries);

(The comicRepository object is initialized in the constructor as before.) The controller code is still very clean, since the work of building the view model is done in ComicRepository.

Finally, the view for the Summary page is also very simple:

@using ComicShop.Models
@model IEnumerable<ComicSummary>

    <h2>Comic summary</h2>
        @foreach (var summary in Model)

The model directive at the top is set to an IEnumerable<ComicSummary> data type, making this a strongly typed view. The rest of the view builds the table by iterating over the elements in the model.

Finally, we can add a GetSummaries() method to our test repository class ComicRepositoryTest. It might look something like this:

    public IEnumerable<ComicSummary> GetSummaries()
      return new[]
        new ComicSummary
          Title = "Superman",
          Count = 3
        new ComicSummary
          Title = "Thor",
          Count = 12

We manually add a couple of ComicSummary objects to a list and return it. To use this, we can add some tests to HomeControllerTests. For example, we can test that the number of entries in the table is 2:

    public void Summary_Count()
      HomeController homeController = new HomeController(
        new ComicRepositoryTest());
      var summary = homeController.Summary();
      var table = summary.Model as ICollection<ComicSummary>;
      Assert.IsTrue(table.Count == 2, "Count is {0}", table.Count);

Since IEnumerable <T> doesn’t support a Count property, we’ve cast the Model field of ‘summary’ to an ICollection, which does have a Count. ICollection inherits IEnumerable, so the cast is valid providing the underlying object implements ICollection, which in this case it does.

Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: